Gilded, not Golden
AI, Trump and the aesthetics of the lowest common denominator
Why is almost everything to do with AI so ugly? The question I start from is Carissa Véliz’s. She teaches philosophy at Oxford and has spent years studying how technology turns into power. Working on the aesthetics of artificial intelligence, she sets out the question in a short essay. I think she is right, and the question deserves to be taken more seriously than it sounds. The ugliness of AI is not a design accident. It is a portrait.
A generated image is not born of an idea. It is born of an average. Hito Steyerl calls them mean images, and in English the word holds both senses: average, and petty. In place of likeness, she writes, they put probability. A team led by Arend Hintze at Dalarna University in Sweden ran an experiment that looks like a parlour game. One model generates an image, a second model describes it, the description goes back to the first, and so on for a hundred rounds. A hundred different starting points all ended up on twelve recurring subjects: gothic cathedrals, lighthouses in a storm, cities at night, rustic interiors. A prompt about a prime minister landed in a plush sitting room with red sofas and heavy drapes. The authors’ most likely explanation is that the machine drifts back to what we photograph most.
That is why AI is also a mirror, and a merciless one. We are what we use to represent ourselves, and what we use has nothing original in it. The machine has no taste, but the average it hands back is ours. When it hands back a sitting room with red sofas, it is telling us what we picture when we think of power. We lack imagination, and we have put it in writing across billions of photographs.
The subtlest stage comes when the average stops being visible. In a study in Psychological Science, generated faces were judged human more often than real ones, precisely because they were more average. The people who got it most wrong were also the ones most confident in their judgement. Words work the same way. Non-expert readers cannot tell poems written by a model from those of Shakespeare, Dickinson or Plath, and they prefer the model’s because they are simpler. The average does not just imitate the real. It becomes the measure of it, and it is liked precisely because it is average. And ugliness feeds ugliness. A recent meta-analysis of nineteen experiments finds that people who create with AI produce work more alike, and that the effect may persist after they stop using it. Taste is cultivated, so it can also be unlearned.
Véliz also names an aesthetics of domination, and there is little to add to that. When Palantir, the data analytics company that works for armies and police forces, covered American campuses in black posters announcing that it builds technology “to dominate”, the aesthetic and the product were one and the same. The people who build these machines have made them in their own image.
No one, though, embodies the society of the lowest common denominator better than Donald Trump. In August 2025 he signed an executive order, a presidential directive that binds the federal administration without going through Congress, making classical style the rule for public buildings. His idea of classical style, however, is scaled down to his capacity to understand it. Then he started building. Where the East Wing of the White House stood until it was demolished, a new ballroom is going up that could cost more than a billion dollars. The first design included a staircase that led nowhere and fake windows to hide the bathrooms. The Reflecting Pool, the long basin in front of the Lincoln Memorial, has been painted blue, “American flag blue”. The contract went without tender to a firm that, by the president’s own account, had worked on the pool at one of his golf clubs. The Oval Office is covered in gold. Trump says it is 24 karat and that foreign leaders “freak out” when they see it. Meanwhile there is a credible suspicion that the cherubs and mouldings are catalogue polyurethane sprayed gold, and the manufacturer has said they could be its own. We will probably never know. But it would change nothing: that gold is not there to be beautiful. It is there to say what it cost.
It is classicism as a hotel understands it. Vitruvius, the Roman architect on whom the canon was built, asked a building for firmness, usefulness and beauty. A staircase that leads nowhere betrays all three. To judge Trump you don’t need the taste of the elite. The canon he claims to love, and cannot recognise, is enough. He stands to classicism as lift music stands to the Berliner Philharmoniker. People go to hear the Berliner because they demand attention, so you can take in even the faintest nuances; lift music is made not to be listened to. Kitsch has nothing to do with it, at least not the kind that is now a conscious code, a chosen excess that remains taste even when it overflows. Nothing here was chosen. There is the average, under a coat of gold worn the way rappers wore it in the nineties: to signal value, not to look for form.
No surprise, then, that Trump loves generated images. In February 2025 he shared a video of Gaza, made with AI, that turned the Strip into a resort with a golden statue of himself. A month later the official White House account posted, in the style of Miyazaki’s films, the arrest of a Dominican woman detained by ICE, the federal immigration police. It used the tenderness of Ghibli for a deportation. Trump’s taste and the machine’s average arrive in the same sitting room with the red sofas. The machine does not know it is doing politics. But the aesthetic it is made of becomes the perfect instrument for those who govern through those images.
In August I wrote that a well-made piece of work no longer vouches for the person who made it, because models have made care cheap. I saw the next step in the Oval Office. When the cost of making stops being proof, the display of cost takes its place. Thorstein Veblen described it in 1899 as pecuniary taste: the expensive mistaken for the beautiful. AI brings the cost of producing a form down to zero. The society of the lowest common denominator answers by showing the price. The machine’s gloss and the gold leaf cover the same void: the choice that is missing.
Mark Twain called his era The Gilded Age: golden on the surface, a thin layer of gold over base metal. That too was an age of rapacious industrialists, but some of them left something public: Andrew Carnegie paid for more than two thousand five hundred libraries. Véliz asks what the architectural legacy of the tech titans will be, and answers: data centres and bunkers. Trump, announcing a five-hundred-billion-dollar investment in AI infrastructure, called data centres “big, beautiful buildings”. Our Gilded Age has lost even the public gilding: the gold stays inside the Oval Office, and outside there are buildings without windows.
One could take comfort in thinking Trump is an exception. He isn’t. He is the paradigm of a society that can no longer tell the original from the replica, and the machine shows it to us without mercy, because it learns from us. The trouble is that now we learn from it too. Who will cultivate taste, if the teacher is the average?